Questions and Answers

Frequently Asked Questions

Q What is fouling release?

A Historically, marine antifouling paints have used compounds toxic to marine organisms as a means of combating fouling. Foul-release coatings don't use copper or any other metal toxicant to provide effective biofouling control; rather their unique surface chemistry creates a surface to which fouling can not easily adhere. Because they employ a physical rather than a chemical means to reduce fouling, these silicone coatings have been ruled exempt from reporting under FIFRA (Public Law 95-396). NRL developed and patented an advanced foul- release coating system called the duplex silicone coating system to address the durability issues associated with silicone elastomeric coatings. This system employs a tough, cross-linked thermoplastic elastomeric layer (Silgan J501, Wacker Chemie, Ltd.) to bond the foul-release silicone topcoat to the anticorrosive system for ship hulls or to epoxy paint on concrete walls in power plants. The ESTCP demonstrations/validations included 6 Coast Guard aluminum hull boats, 2 Navy Range Boats, a Navy Transporter, an ONR/Lockheed prototype (SLICE) and power plant cooling water intakes (concrete walls, steel trash racks/traveling screens/deflecting veins). Barnacle adhesion measurements (ASTM D 5618-94). Barnacle adhesion measurements and water jet cleaning were developed as part of this project.

Back to Top

Q Who would benefit from using the silicone DFR system?

A Any business, organization or agency (public, private, government) whose physical assets are adversely affected by biofouling organisms and/or whose operating equipment performance and efficiency is adversely affected by biofouling organisms. Additionally, any business, organization or agency that might experience enhanced performance or operating efficiencies due to the superior hydrodynamic properties of silicone. Major markets of opportunity include:

  • Marine – Immersed hulls and structures of commercial and military vessels (new-builds and maintenance & repair), fast moving patrol vessels, ferries, container vessels, reefers, LNG/LPG Carriers, Cruise Liners, Ro Ro’s, vehicle carriers, crew boats, large pleasure craft, mega yachts.
  • Power Generation (fossil fuel, nuclear, hydro) - structures and operating equipment including intake tunnels & tubes, trash racks, gates, water boxes, circulating condenser water system, service water system, traveling screens, penstocks.
  • Other industrial or municipal facilities with high water usage including Pulp & Paper and Water Treatment
  • Emerging Technologies – immersed structures of wave and tidal power generation operations

Back to Top

Q Are there markets where the silicone foul release system should not be sold?

A All vessels large and small will benefit from the Duplex Fouling Release Coating System. At this time, however, FHSM has not formulated the Duplex Fouling Release Coating System for hand application by untrained or D-I-Y applicators. Therefore, the smaller vessel owner should contact their FHSM representative for information and recommendations

Back to Top

Q What is the significance of the “Duplex” terminology?

A Duplex refers to the ability of the Tie Coat to create superior adhesion and durability between the system’s vastly different epoxy anti-corrosive layer and the silicone Surface Coat, effectively interlocking the two by employing a unique thermoplastic elastomeric formula. Additionally, the original Duplex name came from the use of two silicone Tie Coat and Surface Coat layers to achieve a superior overall system from the point of view of toughness, durability and foul release.

Back to Top

Q What makes up the total DFR system?

A The full system consists of four coats:

  1. First coat – Marine or Industrial Immersion grade anti-corrosive / barrier epoxy or epoxy sealer in the case of application over concrete
  2. Second coat - Marine/Immersion grade anti-corrosive / barrier epoxy to which FHSM’s tethering agent is added.
  3. FHSM Tie Coat. The Tie Coat is the heart of the Duplex System, imparting superior adhesion and toughness to the system while maintaining superb fouling release properties.
  4. FHSM Surface Coat. The Surface Coat incorporates RTV silicone with added proprietary silicone oils for enhanced biofouling release properties.

Back to Top

Q Are all four coats always required?

A Yes and no, as it depends on the circumstances of the particular project

  1. In cases of new construction or where the total life of any existing coating/coating system has been exceeded, all four coats are required.
  2. In cases where any existing intermediate and or topcoats are worn away, damaged, peeling or otherwise deemed no longer functional then cleaning and removal down to a sound existing epoxy layer is acceptable. Following cleaning and preparation, a three coat system is acceptable as follows:
    • Epoxy coat - Marine/Immersion grade anti-corrosive / barrier epoxy to which FHSM’s tethering agent is added at 15% by volume (19.2 ounces per gallon)
    • FHSM Tie Coat
    • FHSM Surface Coat
  3. In maintenance cases, it is possible that just a refresher coat of silicone Surface Coat would be required after appropriate cleaning and preparation.
  4. The number of coats for repair procedures will vary depending upon the extent of damage to the coating system

Back to Top

Q Along the same lines as the previous question, can the silicone foul release coatings be applied over an existing system?

A Yes, as long as all contaminants and loose paint are removed leaving a solid, intact surface that will accept epoxy paint.

Back to Top

Q What surface preparation is required?

A For ferrous and non-ferrous metals, SSPC-SP6 Commercial Blast Cleaning, or SSPC-SP12 Water-jetting to WJ-2. A bare substrate is a preferred with a profile depth of 3 mils. For concrete, SSPC-SP13 Surface Preparation of Concrete.

Back to Top

Q Can silicones become brittle with age and or heat?

A FHSM’s silicone is similar to that used in the highest-grade outdoor caulking. That does not become brittle with age, heat or UV exposure, and is guaranteed by the manufacturer for 30 years. Excellent resistance to aging and the environment is one of the unique properties of silicones compared to other polymers. It is because silicones are based on silicon and oxygen polymer chains rather than carbon based polymer chains that these outstanding performance properties can be achieved.

Back to Top

Q How is the FHSM Duplex Fouling Release system different from other silicone foul release systems?

A The other silicone fouling release systems have a similar surface coat silicone to the FHSM. However, that is where the similarities end. The differences are three fold:

  1. Due to the unique properties of the Tie Coat and the use of special bonding chemistries at the epoxy – Tie Coat interface, the FHSM system has been engineered for superior adhesion and strength compared to the other silicone systems. This will translate into improved resistance to delamination and longer service life.
  2. The FHSM system is thicker than competitive products ensuring superior strength, durability and life expectancy.
  3. FHSM incorporates a superior release, proprietary silicone oil in the Surface Coat that creates a system where by very low fouling release speeds can be achieved.
  4. The Duplex Fouling Release System has unique self-leveling characteristics that result in a super-smooth surface. This property results in speed and fuel efficiencies greater than 10% as compared to traditional copper ablative systems in marine applications. Further, this super-smooth characteristic may contribute to improved flow efficiencies in power generating water systems.

Back to Top

Q Under what conditions can the foul release properties of the FSHM system be expected to work?

A The FHSM system releases hard fouling on vessels at a range of: low speeds 10 knots - higher speeds of 42 knots as proven by the US Navy. Recent field trials have demonstrated success below and above proven ranges mentioned above.

For circulating and service water tunnels and other structures in power generation facilities, a season long (May to October) field trial in Lake Ontario demonstrated fouling release/self cleaning at flow rates as low as 0.5 ft/sec. in fresh water. In salt and brackish water with a constant flow rate as low as 7 ft/sec., biofouling organisms are unable to attach to intake surfaces and other related structures.

Back to Top

Q Does the Duplex Coating System offer other advantages in addition to the fouling release properties?

A Yes, because boat bottoms remain clean and free of bio-fouling and because of the slick and hydrophobic properties of the silicone Surface Coat, speeds increase and fuel consumption declines. In one recent sea trial, a ship’s speed increased 10+% compared to a copper ablative anti-fouling coating when operated at the same engine RPM’s and the fuel consumption dropped 10%. Results for other craft will vary depending on but not limited to such factors as hull design, weight, equipment maintenance, operating conditions and sea conditions.

For power plants, the early results of flow efficiency study when saltwater is pumped through penstocks suggests that an improvement in terms of energy savings can be as much as 18% in steel pipes coated with the Duplex System and as high as 55% in concrete pipes coated with the Duplex System. This study continues with the goal of defining savings as a monetary value per Mega Watt or Kilo Watt.

Back to Top

Q Are EPA, California or other local registrations needed?

A The EPA does not require special certifications for the FHSM Duplex Fouling Release System (DFRS). Silicones in general are not seen as hazardous to the environment. The U.S. Navy received a Federal Insecticide, Fungicide, and Rodenticide Act (FIFRA) exemption during their field-testing. In fact, the surface coat is FDA compliant for contact with food. Furthermore, FHSM is not aware of any special regulations from California.

Back to Top

Q Is the product VOC compliant?

A Yes, the Tie Coat and Surface Coat products in the system are VOC compliant at 1.3 lb/gal or 156 g/L.

Back to Top

Q How is silicone applied? What equipment?

A Application can be by brush, roll or airless spray. Recommended airless spray equipment is GRACO King 56 to 1 Hydra-Spray or larger pump or equivalents of other manufacturers. Use 0.021 tip or larger for the Tie Coat and 0.021 tip or larger for the Surface Coat.

Back to Top

Q Is the silicone sensitive to moisture?

A In its cured state, moisture will not degrade or damage the silicone itself. However, silicone is more permeable to water vapor than other types of polymers. Thus a silicone coating by itself is not a good corrosion barrier. However, the underlying tie coat and epoxy layers are very good moisture and corrosion resistance barriers. Thus, the overall system is a good moisture and corrosion barrier.

The application of silicone is moisture sensitive, and it is harder to apply under damp conditions. Silicone should be applied when surface to be coated is at least 5 degrees above the dew point as with most epoxies. The humidity range is 30 to 85%. Mechanical means can be used to regulate humidity levels. The surface should be clean and dry to promote proper adhesion. Prior to application of the Duplex System, a FUJI Hunt Smart Surfaces representative should be notified if any conditions outside of these parameters exist.

Back to Top

Q How is a silicone system maintained or repaired?

A Minor scratches can be recoated with Surface Coat after cleaning surface with thinner to remove any surface contaminants.

Areas damaged down to bare substrate will require the bare steel only to be cleaned and two coats of epoxy (2nd epoxy with tethering agent) and Tie Coat to be applied to this area only (do not overlap existing Surface Coat), then Surface Coat application.

For other damage down to but not into the Tie Coat, then only Surface Coat re-application would be needed.

Back to Top

Q How do we protect other areas from ‘silicone pest’ (“fish eyes”)?

A By containment methods: tarps, screens, isolation, etc

Back to Top

Q What is the shelf life of the Tie Coat and Surface Coat silicone products?

A The shelf life is 1 year from date of manufacture in the container.

Back to Top

Q What is the service life for the FHSM Duplex Fouling Release silicone system?

A Five (5) years as indicated in the FHSM warranties. Silicones are known to have long service life due to the properties discussed above, so lifetimes greater than 5 years are quite possible.

Back to Top

Q Does FHSM provide technical service?

A Yes, both by phone for questions and for site evaluations, inspections and applications. A FSHM technical representative on site during application is required when a warranty is desired.

Back to Top

Q Does FHSM offer a warranty?

A Yes, two warranties are available. One warranty is offered for marine projects and the other for industrial/power projects. Both warranties are for a five (5) year period.

Back to Top

Q What is the difference between the two warranties?

A The marine warranty includes a “fuel savings for commercial vessels” component stating that such vessels shall experience a 3% decrease in fuel consumed where the DFR system is applied. Refer to the warranty document for details of fuel monitoring procedures and historical records both prior to and during the warranty period

Back to Top